Based on your seastead design—specifically the high-drag semi-submersible configuration (30,000 lbs displacement, 4-ft diameter columns, target 1 MPH)—you will likely need **800–1,200 lbs of continuous bollard thrust** to overcome wave drag and current. This puts single-unit solutions at their limit; you will likely need **2–4 units** or one heavy industrial mixer. Regarding **Chinese RIM Drive links**: I cannot provide verified URLs because these manufacturers frequently change domains, use Alibaba/TaoBao portals that expire, or operate only via direct contact. I have included placeholder entries with search terms. Here is your comparison table in HTML format: ```html
Values are approximate bollard pull (static thrust). Prices are USD estimates for single units (retail/industrial).
| Type | Lbs Thrust | Watts | lbs/kW | $ Price | $/lb-thrust | URL / Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RIM Drive (Yamaha HARMO) | 227 | 3,700 | 61.4 | $3,500 | $15.42 | yamaha-motor.co.jp |
| Submersible Mixer (Flygt SR 4640) | 720 | 3,200 | 225 | $12,000 | $16.67 | xylem.com (Search SR 4640) |
| Submersible Mixer (Vaughan V-Series) | 650 | 3,500 | 186 | $10,500 | $16.15 | chopperpumps.com |
| RIM Thruster (Side-Power SE60/185) | 132 | 2,200 | 60.0 | $4,200 | $31.82 | sidepower.com |
| RIM Drive (Brunvoll RDW-500) | 1,100 | 7,500 | 147 | $28,000 | $25.45 | brunvoll.com |
| Chinese RIM Drive (Generic)* | 350 | 3,000 | 117 | $1,800 | $5.14 | Search: "Rim drive thruster 3KW underwater" on Alibaba/1688.com |
| DIY Kort Nozzle + Industrial Motor | 400 | 4,000 | 100 | $2,000 | $5.00 | N/A (Fabricate locally) |
| Ducted Azimuth (Thrustmaster EDD-200) | 880 | 8,000 | 110 | $18,000 | $20.45 | thrustmaster.net |
| Electric Paddle Wheel (DIY)** | 600 | 5,500 | 109 | $3,500 | $5.83 | Custom build with 48V forklift motor |
* Chinese RIM Drives: Look for manufacturers in Jiangsu or Guangdong provinces. Verify IP68 rating and anti-corrosion coating (Alodine/Hard Anodize). Many listings are for ROVs (too small); you need fishing boat scale.
** Paddle wheels are extremely efficient for 0–2 MPH speeds with heavy displacement and can be lifted out of water when not in use (reducing biofouling).
Power Reality Check: At 1 MPH, your 4-ft diameter columns (projected area ~160 sq ft total) will create approximately 600–900 lbs of drag depending on current. You need surplus thrust for station-keeping. Budget for at least 4–5 kWh of battery per hour of operation (accounting for motor/controller losses).
``` **Key Findings:** - **No larger commercial RIM Drive** beats the HARMO's $/thrust ratio; marine rim drives jump to ship-scale ($20k+). - **Chinese RIM Drives** exist (3–5 kW range) but are hard to verify; expect 6–8 week lead times and request salt-water corrosion test data. - **Submersible mixers** remain the thrust/kW champion but are heavy (300+ lbs each) and require rigid mounting to your float columns. For redundancy with your cable system, I recommend **two independent thrusters** (port/starboard) rather than one large central unit.