```html
Drag Analysis: Wing-Legged Seastead
Drag Analysis: Wing-Shaped Legs on a Trimaran-Style Seastead
1. Chord and Thickness — What NACA Profile Are We Talking About?
A 10 ft chord with a 3 ft maximum thickness gives a thickness-to-chord ratio (t/c) of 30%.
That is very thick by aerodynamic standards. Typical airfoils are 12–18% t/c. NACA symmetric
sections like the 0030 do exist (used for strut-type submerged bodies and sometimes keels on
heavy sailboats), so there is published data.
2. Drag Coefficient Estimate for a 30%-Thick Strut
For a well-faired symmetric NACA-style section at low angle of attack, the drag coefficient
(based on chord × span, the "planform" reference) in fully submerged flow is roughly:
| Section | t/c | CD (planform-based) |
| NACA 0012 | 12% | ~0.0085 |
| NACA 0018 | 18% | ~0.011 |
| NACA 0024 | 24% | ~0.015 |
| NACA 0030 (your shape) | 30% | ~0.020–0.025 |
| Circular cylinder (same thickness) | — | ~0.8–1.0 |
Important: these CD numbers are non-dimensionalized on different reference areas, so the
raw numbers aren't directly comparable. What matters is the actual drag force, shown below.
3. Drag vs. an Equal-Volume Round Cylinder
Each leg is 19 ft long, chord 10 ft, thickness 3 ft, with only the bottom ~9.5 ft submerged.
Cross-section area of a NACA 0030 is about 0.68 × chord × thickness ≈ 20.4 ft² per leg.
An equivalent round cylinder would be about 5.1 ft diameter to match that volume.
At 4 knots (2.06 m/s) in seawater (ρ = 1025 kg/m³):
| Shape | Reference area (submerged) | CD | Drag per leg |
| Wing-shaped leg (chord × submerged span) | 10 × 9.5 = 95 ft² (8.83 m²) | 0.022 | ~9 lbf |
| Round cylinder, same volume (5.1 ft dia) | 5.1 × 9.5 = 48.5 ft² (4.50 m²) | 0.9 | ~190 lbf |
At 6 knots (3.09 m/s):
| Shape | Drag per leg | Drag, 3 legs total |
| Wing-shaped leg | ~21 lbf | ~60–65 lbf |
| Equal-volume cylinder | ~430 lbf | ~1,300 lbf |
Bottom line: Even though your foil is a very fat 30%, it still has roughly
4–6% of the drag of a round cylinder of the same displacement. The streamlining is
enormously effective. The comparison to a cylinder of the same thickness (not volume)
would be even more dramatic (~2%).
4. Add the Wave-Making and Appendage Drag
The numbers above are viscous (friction + form) drag only. For a semi-submersible–style hull
piercing the surface, you also get:
- Wave-making drag: Small waterplane-area platforms make very little waves at
low speed. Your waterplane per leg is only 10 × 3 = 30 ft², times 3 = 90 ft² total. Expect
wave drag of just tens of pounds at 4–6 knots.
- Six RIM thruster pods: Each adds maybe 5–15 lbf at 6 kn. Call it ~50 lbf total.
- Three stabilizer "airplanes": Tiny — a few pounds each.
Total realistic hydrodynamic drag at 6 knots: roughly 150–250 lbf.
At 4 knots: roughly 60–110 lbf.
5. Comparison to a Trawler or Catamaran
Same displacement (~15–25 tons)
| Vessel | Drag @ 6 kn | Notes |
| 40–45 ft monohull trawler, ~20 t | ~350–500 lbf | Large wetted area, significant wave drag near hull speed. |
| 40 ft cruising catamaran, ~10–15 t | ~200–300 lbf | Slender hulls, low wave drag. |
| Your seastead (3 foil legs) | ~150–250 lbf | Very low wave-making, modest friction area. |
Same length (80 ft)
| Vessel | Typical displacement | Drag @ 6 kn |
| 80 ft trawler | 80–120 t | ~1,500–3,000 lbf |
| 80 ft performance cat | 20–30 t | ~400–700 lbf |
| Your seastead | 15–25 t | ~150–250 lbf |
At displacement speeds, your design should need roughly 1/3 to 1/10 the thrust of a
comparable trawler, and roughly half to two-thirds of a modern cruising cat of the
same weight. The trade-off is you do not plane and you are limited in top speed by the short
waterline (~4.5–6 kn practical cruise).
6. Why the Fat Foil Still Works Well
- Viscous pressure drag grows with t/c, but only gradually until flow separation becomes an issue. NACA 00xx sections up to ~30% t/c generally keep attached flow at low angle of attack.
- The "blunt" leading edge you describe is actually the rounded edge of the NACA profile — exactly what you want for insensitivity to small yaw angles and for bi-directional cross-current performance.
- Small waterplane area means pitch and heave forcing by waves is small, so motions stay gentle even though the legs are "fat."
7. Have I Seen This Before?
A few partial relatives exist, but nothing quite like what you describe:
- SWATH vessels (Small Waterplane Area Twin Hull) — e.g., the SSP Kaimalino, Navatek, the Sea Shadow (IX-529), and various SWATH ferries. These use submerged torpedo-shaped pods with thin surface-piercing struts. Your legs are the "strut" but also serve as the buoyancy — a merged concept.
- Semi-submersible oil platforms — round or square columns, almost always optimized for station-keeping, not translation. Your wing-shaped columns are a clear improvement for mobility.
- Trimaran SWATH concepts — proposed in naval research papers but rarely built at small scale.
- Wing-sail trimarans — unrelated; the "wing" is above water.
I am not aware of any production or well-known experimental vessel that combines: (a)
three surface-piercing foil-shaped columns, (b) arranged at the corners of a wide
triangular deck, and (c) sized to be a mobile small-waterplane seastead with distributed
thrust. It is a genuinely interesting niche — essentially a trimaran-SWATH hybrid optimized
for solar area rather than speed.
8. Practical Caveats
- At yaw/sideslip angles > ~8°, a 30% t/c foil can stall and drag rises sharply. Crosswinds and currents should be managed by the thrusters.
- Wave drag estimates assume deep, calm water. In a seaway, added resistance from pitching through waves can double the calm-water figure.
- The top halves of the legs will experience wind drag — the foil shape helps here too, though the blunt LE is less ideal for the prevailing wind direction.
- Verify metacentric height carefully — small waterplane area means low stiffness. Three widely-spaced legs help, but loading distribution matters.
Summary numbers to remember:
• Wing-leg CD ≈ 0.02 (planform-based)
• ~5% of the drag of an equal-volume round column
• Total hydrodynamic drag at 6 kn: roughly 150–250 lbf
• Roughly 1/2 a same-weight cat, 1/3–1/10 a same-length trawler
```